Top 12 Pepperoni Pizzas in America That Are Totally Worth the Calories

When it comes to iconic American comfort food, few dishes hit the spot like a hot, cheesy pepperoni pizza. It’s crispy, savory, slightly spicy, and loaded with flavor—making it a go-to favorite from coast to coast. But not all pepperoni pizzas are created equal. Some rise above the rest with crispy, cupped pepperoni, golden-brown crusts, and sauces that balance sweetness and tang perfectly.

Whether you’re craving a classic New York slice, a Detroit-style deep dish, or a creative gourmet twist, we’ve rounded up the top 12 pepperoni pizzas in America that are totally worth the calories. These mouthwatering pies aren’t just meals—they’re experiences. From small-town gems to famous national chains, each pick on this list delivers serious flavor that pizza lovers can’t get enough of. Ready to fuel your next pizza craving? Let’s dive into the best pepperoni pies the country has to offer.

1. Prince Street Pizza – New York City, NY

Prince Street Pizza in NYC is a pepperoni paradise. Known for their thick, square Sicilian-style slices, they pile on spicy, cup-and-char pepperoni that crisps up perfectly in the oven. The “Spicy Spring” slice, their most iconic, features tangy tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and loads of those delicious pepperoni cups that curl at the edges and trap tiny pools of oil. It’s the kind of indulgent, greasy goodness that leaves your fingers shiny and your taste buds begging for more.

The crust is thick but airy, with a golden-brown bottom that holds its shape and delivers a satisfying crunch with every bite. The cheese is rich and gooey, balancing the spice from the meat. Whether you’re a local or tourist, this spot is almost always buzzing, and it’s not hard to see why. If you’re in Manhattan and craving top-tier pepperoni pizza, Prince Street should be your first stop—calories be damned.

2. Pepperoni’s Tavern – Alpharetta, GA

Don’t let the casual vibe fool you—Pepperoni’s Tavern in Alpharetta serves up some of the most crave-worthy pepperoni pies in the South. Their dough is handmade daily, resulting in a crispy yet chewy crust that acts as the perfect base for their generous toppings. Their pepperoni pizza is a classic done right, featuring zesty marinara sauce, a special blend of mozzarella, and a heap of curled pepperoni slices that are just the right amount of crispy and juicy.

What makes their version shine is the balance of spice and salt from the pepperoni, cut by a subtly sweet tomato sauce. Each bite melts in your mouth and leaves you with a warm, satisfying burn that lingers in the best way. Whether you’re watching the game, catching up with friends, or dining solo, Pepperoni’s Tavern offers comfort, flavor, and calories that are 100% worth it. You’ll be coming back slice after slice.

3. Tony’s Pizza Napoletana – San Francisco, CA

Located in the heart of San Francisco’s North Beach, Tony’s Pizza Napoletana is the brainchild of 13-time World Pizza Champion Tony Gemignani. His pepperoni pizza isn’t just a meal—it’s a masterclass in flavor and craftsmanship. The New York-style option is a standout, showcasing hand-stretched dough made from artisan flour and fermented for over 72 hours. Topped with rich, house-made sauce and finished with Wisconsin mozzarella and premium pepperoni that crisps beautifully in the oven, each slice is bursting with umami and spice.

The crust is thin but not floppy, with a perfect char and a doughy bite near the rim. This pizza balances textures and tastes so well, it’s hard to stop at just one slice. The pepperoni is slightly smoky with a peppery finish, making it unforgettable. Whether you’re a local or a foodie traveler, this award-winning pizzeria delivers a pepperoni experience that fully justifies every delicious calorie.

4. Di Fara Pizza – Brooklyn, NY

Di Fara Pizza is a New York institution and for good reason. Founded by Dom DeMarco in 1965, this family-run pizzeria crafts its legendary pies with imported Italian ingredients and old-school technique. Their pepperoni pizza is nothing short of divine. The crust has that iconic Brooklyn chew—thin, with a crispy bottom and doughy edge that absorbs flavor without getting soggy. Topped with sweet San Marzano tomato sauce, a blend of mozzarella and Parmigiano-Reggiano, and thick-sliced pepperoni, it’s the kind of pizza that feels both nostalgic and gourmet.

Each slice is hand-finished with a drizzle of olive oil and a sprinkle of fresh basil, adding a light, herby lift to balance the rich meat. It’s a greasy, cheesy, slightly spicy experience that makes no apologies for being indulgent. Di Fara proves that sometimes simple ingredients, when treated with respect, can yield the most unforgettable flavors—definitely worth every calorie and then some.

5. Lou Malnati’s – Chicago, IL

If you’re in the mood for a deep-dish masterpiece, Lou Malnati’s in Chicago should be your go-to for pepperoni pizza that sticks to your ribs in the best way. Their buttery crust is a revelation—crispy on the bottom, tender throughout, and thick enough to hold a mountain of toppings. The pepperoni here is layered under a generous helping of gooey mozzarella cheese, locking in its flavor and juices.

Then comes their signature chunky tomato sauce, which adds brightness and contrast. Unlike traditional thin-crust pies, this version lets the pepperoni steam inside the pizza, releasing all its spicy oils directly into the cheese and crust. It’s a rich, filling, utterly comforting dish that feels like a warm hug on a plate. Each slice is a meal in itself, and though it’s heavy, the flavor complexity makes it impossible to resist. Lou Malnati’s makes every calorie count—and then doubles down.

6. Pizzeria Beddia – Philadelphia, PA

Pizzeria Beddia in Philadelphia doesn’t just make pizza—it elevates it into an art form. This small, minimalist spot has gained national fame for its carefully crafted pies, and their pepperoni version is a prime example. The dough undergoes a long fermentation process, resulting in a crust that’s airy yet sturdy, with perfect blistering along the edge. Their sauce is bright and tangy, made from high-quality tomatoes that balance the saltiness of the mozzarella and the spicy, curled pepperoni slices.

Beddia’s pepperoni is thick-cut and charred just right, releasing a bold, meaty flavor that pairs perfectly with their signature red sauce. Each bite is thoughtfully balanced: chewy crust, acidic tomato, stretchy cheese, and crisp meat. The entire pie feels both elevated and comforting, and while the price may be higher than your average slice, the flavor more than justifies it. It’s a calorie-laden culinary statement that any true pizza lover will gladly devour.

7. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana – New Haven, CT

A legendary name in the world of American pizza, Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana has been serving coal-fired perfection since 1925. While they’re best known for their white clam pizza, their pepperoni pie deserves just as much praise. The coal oven delivers a crispy, slightly charred crust that adds a smoky depth to every slice. Their tomato sauce is subtly sweet and savory, layered beneath bubbling, fresh mozzarella.

The pepperoni is sliced thin and placed generously across the pie, curling at the edges and crisping up from the intense heat of the oven. Each bite delivers a satisfying contrast between crunchy crust, creamy cheese, and spicy pepperoni. What sets Pepe’s apart is its consistent quality—no matter when you go, every pizza is made with care. It’s a classic New Haven experience that combines tradition and indulgence in every delicious calorie. If you’re road-tripping for pizza, this one’s worth the detour.

8. Joe’s Pizza – New York City, NY

Joe’s Pizza is the epitome of the classic New York slice, and their pepperoni version hits all the right notes. Located in Greenwich Village since 1975, Joe’s serves up thin, foldable slices with a loyal fan base that spans celebrities and tourists alike. The pepperoni pizza here features large, thin slices of slightly spicy pepperoni that distribute flavor evenly across the pie. Their sauce is bold and seasoned just right, providing the perfect backdrop for the melted mozzarella and crispy crust.

What makes Joe’s so special is the balance—no ingredient overwhelms the others. It’s cheesy, meaty, saucy, and crunchy in perfect proportion. It’s the kind of slice you can grab on the go or savor slowly while sitting on a park bench. While it might look like a simple street slice, the taste is pure New York excellence. If you’re counting calories, skip it—this one’s worth the indulgence.

9. Roberta’s – Brooklyn, NY

Located in the heart of Bushwick, Roberta’s has redefined what it means to be a trendy pizza joint—and their pepperoni pizza is both stylish and seriously good. Baked in wood-fired ovens, their crust comes out beautifully blistered and chewy with that addictive sourdough tang. The tomato sauce is fresh and slightly sweet, made from organic San Marzano tomatoes, while the mozzarella is creamy and stretchy.

Their pepperoni isn’t your run-of-the-mill variety—it’s artisanally cured, sliced thicker, and finished with a bit of fennel or spice depending on the batch. Once baked, the edges crisp up and the oils seep into the cheese and crust, making every bite rich and savory. Roberta’s often adds a drizzle of local honey or chili oil for an optional twist, which pairs surprisingly well with the pepperoni’s spice. It’s hip, yes, but it’s also heartfelt pizza-making that delivers serious flavor—and calories worth every single bite.

10. Sally’s Apizza – New Haven, CT

Another New Haven legend, Sally’s Apizza offers a different but equally delicious approach to pepperoni pizza. Founded in 1938, this pizzeria has been serving pies out of a coal-fired oven that imparts a distinctive char and crispness. Sally’s crust is ultra-thin with a nice snap at the bottom and just enough chew to hold the toppings. Their sauce is slightly tangy, spread thin to avoid sogginess, and their mozzarella cheese is melted to golden perfection.

The pepperoni at Sally’s is the standout—it’s not greasy, overly salty, or overpowering. Instead, it’s got a refined, meaty flavor with a hint of heat that enhances the overall experience. Their technique ensures every slice is perfectly balanced, never overloaded but always satisfying. This is the kind of pizza you don’t even need to dress up—it’s just as good eaten straight from the box. Each slice is a throwback to tradition and a celebration of taste.

11. Serious Pie – Seattle, WA

Serious Pie, founded by renowned chef Tom Douglas, takes a gourmet approach to pizza while still honoring traditional roots. Their pepperoni pizza features a hand-crafted dough that’s fermented for days, producing a light, airy crust with a delicious chew and a hint of sourdough funk. Cooked in a wood-fired oven, the crust chars on the outside but stays tender on the inside. The sauce is slightly sweet and herbaceous, while the mozzarella and provolone blend melts into a creamy, bubbling layer of goodness.

Their house-cured pepperoni steals the show—it’s thick, juicy, and curled into crispy cups that hold flavorful oils in every bite. Finished with a sprinkle of sea salt and sometimes a drizzle of chili-infused honey, it’s a spicy-sweet masterpiece. Serious Pie lives up to its name by treating each ingredient with, well, seriousness. The flavor is so intense and satisfying, you’ll forget about the calories until the last bite’s gone.

12. Gino’s East – Chicago, IL

Gino’s East is synonymous with Chicago deep-dish and their pepperoni pizza is an indulgent tribute to everything fans love about the Windy City’s famous pie. Each pizza begins with their golden, cornmeal-based crust that offers a slightly sweet crunch with a firm base. The pepperoni is layered directly on the crust and then covered with a thick layer of mozzarella cheese, locking in the meaty, spicy flavor. On top of that comes their rich tomato sauce, seasoned with herbs and a hint of garlic.

This inverted layering ensures that each bite is moist, cheesy, and pepperoni-packed. It’s hearty, comforting, and utterly satisfying. The slices are thick and heavy—this is a knife-and-fork kind of pizza—but the flavors are balanced enough that you won’t feel overwhelmed. Gino’s East knows exactly what it’s doing: serving up calorie-heavy, flavor-rich deep-dish that brings a smile to your face and sauce to your chin.

Bottom Line

Pepperoni pizza holds a special place in America’s heart—and stomach. From iconic institutions to underrated local favorites, the 12 pizzas we’ve featured prove that the perfect slice is always worth the indulgence. Whether you’re on a road trip or looking to order the best near you, these spots promise unbeatable pepperoni perfection. Each pizza on this list is crafted with care, quality ingredients, and a whole lot of love for the slice. So don’t count calories—count flavors. Because when it comes to the best pepperoni pizzas in America, every bite is absolutely worth it.

FAQs